Not quite sure what to make of this...
Posted February 7th, 2008 by andy wegman
...but certainly would rather come to a CA clinic than one of these...
http://www.bizjournals.com/baltimore/stories/2008/02/04/daily33.html
Andy in Manchester, NH


I like it!
For me, an Israel-American, ultra-leftist hippee acupunk: this is great. Why? Because I and the Acs I know don't want to live where there are Wal-Marts. We want to live in San Francisco, New York, Boston, Philly, or abroad... or Monterey, Hawaii, Santa Barbara. It's either gotta be hip and happening, or open-minded and beautiful - preferably all 4. By and large, Wal-Marts are in the places we wouldn't want to be. I'm thrilled everytime I hear about an Ac in Iowa or Kansas. I think everyone should be getting acupx (or at least have access to it). But it'll be a while before the average Wal-Mart customer has access to, and interest in acupx. In the meantime, give them affordable healthcare or some kind (even if it's not as good as what we can do) :)
Walmart shoppers and Acupuncture
I don't think the average walmart shopper lacks an interest in acupuncture per say. Many walmarts are located in areas where there is very limited access to acupuncture--let's say rural nebraska, but certainly the people who live in Oxnard, CA--40 miles from Santa Barbara, have at least heard of acupuncture, and there are at least a dozen practitioners in that city. Equating walmart with a population that doesn't want or care about acupuncture is far off the mark. CAPs that are doing well and succeeding in areas like Hawaii, Boston, Philly (where there are plenty walmarts) need to serve as models, support and inspiration to acupunks who want to try CA in less progressive (and less exclusive) places. One hopeful part of me is glad that more access to health care is being created, but the less idealistic part of me wonders how a corporation, who's main goal is profit (and looking good to generate more profit) will dillute the health-care they deliver. Yes some care is better than no care, but leaving basic human services to private corporations can have a lot of negative effects. For example, smaller family practices and clinics may go under because they cannot compete with walmart or the deals it can make with medical suppliers, pharmaceutical companies. The propaganda around corporate healthcare is likely to be like the propaganda around corporate "organics" and "green products". Sure there may be some good coming of these things, but they are married to the desire to capitalize on people's emotions. I was looking at some green clothing online and they list all the positive environmental aspects of their products... and then the punchline...made in China. There's gotta be some punchline with this walmart healthcare. (weren't they just fined for having signs up for selling organic food that wasn't organic? Do you know that Organic valley milk pulled it's products from walmart's shelves because they were being asked to sell their milk for a less than sustainable price? http://www.inc.com/magazine/20070701/casestudy.html)If I let my cynical side take over, it seems as if the government has let the health-care situation in this country become so dire so that corporations like walmart--dat-da-dah!!-- can step in and "save the day." What about healthcare where health is the bottom line? What about healthcare where decisions are made in communities rather than boardrooms? What about healthcare that takes care of the providers, as people, and not just a labor budget. (will the walmart health employees also be forced to work without overtime pay, be locked in the building? given the option of affordable health insurance?) I want to believe this is a step in a positive direction, but my gut tells me no. Cris
Re: Not quite sure what to make of this...
Well, the skeptic in me is thinking about the union-busting element of this. WalMart is infamous for its poor labor practices, especially as regards its female employees; so no troublesome nurses' unions to deal with...
Call me old-fashioned, but I think the common stock (air, water, libraries, etc. - and basic health for citizens) should not be controlled by megacorporations. Partial privatization doesn't seem to have improved the U.S. Postal Service, after all. I'm not always rabidly anticapitalist, but I don't like the scent of this one at all.
Re: Not quite sure what to make of this...
This is really great news! So, even though it's obvious that Wal-Mart wants to be the "good guy" by offering $4 prescriptions and affordable doctor visits, can anyone object to that? Certainly not the uninsured! Anytime an individual or corporation takes the matter of healthcare access into their own hands, we are one step closer to making visible the inherent right of every human being to healthcare.
Marty Calliham
Re: Not quite sure what to make of this...
What I make of it is that Americans are desperate for health care that they can afford. This has been coming for a long time. For example, I heard on the radio a couple of years ago that NH was experiencing a shortage of doctors. I thought to myself, gosh acupunks should go to NH, they would really do well there!
Yey for the Manchester Acunk Studio!
Re: Not quite sure what to make of this...
One day there will be
CA-Mart:
a 500,000 sq ft community room
hourly shipments of found recliners
there will be so many acupuncturist working there that
it will slowly pull centripetally all the acu schools closer to it
all the fleece throws will match and have the corp. logo
it will have it own in house hand sanitizer manufacturing plant
or it won't
there will be dvds( or the modern equivalent)
with romantic movies about the quaint days of boutique CAs
maybe